Summry > Calibrate your monitor 7 / 8
 

i1Display Pro review

 

Review of the i1Display Pro - X-Rite - Part 2Updated on November 3, 2018

 

We will now check the quality of our calibration through some tests before concluding.

It is time to check the quality of the calibration of your display. With the i1 Display Pro colorimeter - a high-end version of X-Rite - it is possible to perform this verification thanks to the software and its sensor (colorimeter) but also by some tests in Photoshop.
In the first, we will check BEFORE/AFTER images, using different tests and we will check the uniformity of the panel.
In Photoshop, we will be able to test the white point, the black point but also the grayscale to know if we have a lot of tone breaks or not...


 
 

In a few words...

 

i1Display Pro - X-Rite

$244.78

Except for the expensive Discus, this i1Display Pro is simply the best monitor calibration sensor on the market today! - Read my conclusion  

 
     
  Other offers...  
 
$244.78
$275.99
$244.78
 
   

 

 

After calibration: software quality control

Once the calibration is done, it is possible to perform a quality control of your screen, your ICC profile, a harmonization of several screens in order to align them, a monitoring over time of your screen, or whatever else!
And it is also possible to optimize the ICC profile almost in real time in relation to the luminance and color temperature of the room.... Let's start with the classic BEFORE/AFTER.

Before/After comparison

ICC profile in 3D in i1ProfilerOnce the ICC profile of the monitor is created and saved, it is then displayed on the monitor and gives us the possibility to make some quick comparisons. For instance, you can see in 3D this ICC profile in the Lab color space, as shown in the illustration on the right. Using the mouse, you are able to manipulate it in all directions, to zoom in and out, to rotate, etc ... Too bad it is not possible to make a comparison at this stage, using transparency. So, it requires a lot of experience to draw conclusions from here

It is also possible to see the three correction curves of the RGB channels between 0 and 255. The comparison with an excellent Graphic Art display as Eizo, mine is already four years old, is revealing : the curves are clearly separated and complexes compared to the Quato, for which the three curves are still flat and stacked. The profile is not of so much use in that case !

Before / After comparison in i1ProfilerFinally, it is possible to compare with the famous before/after a photo reference (it is possible to choose the sample photo among many references) : using the buttons "before/after" in top right, it is easy to compare the state of the display before and after calibration. Do not hesitate to change the picture to check the quality of the calibration according to the colors and intensity levels. On basic monitors, you can very well get a remarkable calibration at certain levels and significantly worse in others. For the best monitors, the question does not even arise !

Display QA - Quality Assurance

Among the major differences, between the so-called expert amators colorimeters and uncompromising colorimeters, are those quality reports. The first one is available from the ICC profile page by clicking on "Display QA" menu of the display profiling workflow or from the Home menu in "Advanced" user mode in the left column menu, under "Display", by clicking on "Display QA". It is especially interesting for those who want to know everything about their monitor.

   
   
 

A new window will open. First, it is necessary to choose the type of reference from which the comparison will be made. The most meaningful is the type of "Standard" patch set selected by default.

   
  The first comparison is the most telling one. The others will interest experts in color management.
 

 

Start the measurement that reviews the 24 colored patches displayed above. To do this, click on the Next button and the "Start measurement" button. It goes very fast, once again, with i1Profiler. Then you will have a full report on your screen and the Delta E.

   
   
  And if you ask for the quality assurance report, you will see this window appear that a novice will have a hard time interpreting. The experts will be delighted to analyse all this information...
   
  Here is one of the best calibration reports obtained after the calibration of the magnificent EIZO CG277 ! That's what it looks like at best....
 

 

Finally, it is possible to follow a screen over time thanks to the "Trend" function which displays the delta E and the deviations over time. Perfect to know if a screen is declining and needs to be changed...

Ambient light measurement

I1Display Pro Sensor Light SensorSome retoucher photographers need to have the maximum control on the color quality of their monitor. However, the ambient light of the room, where they are, is then very important. It is therefore possible to optimize the ICC profile with this ambient light detection, automatically or manually. At regular intervals in automatic mode (every 10, 30 or 60 minutes), a measurement is performed and allows to slightly adjust the way colors are displayed on the monitor.

Note! With the i1Display Pro colorimeter, the measure is made in quantity (luminance) and quality (color temperature) for more accuracy when correcting the ICC profile.

Be careful! If you have a compact fluorescent lighting in your room, this measure is not recommended, because the correction is really bad.

Display uniformity measurement

With this function it is possible to measure nine areas of your monitor to learn more about its homogeneity.

   
   
  Start the measurement (click on the "Start measurement" button) according to the instructions, so simple once having selected the monitor to evaluate ! As the measurement goes on, the color temperature of the white point and luminance of each area appear ... with possibly good or bad surprises !
   
   
 

It is possible, once the results are displayed, to select the tolerance level of luminance and color temperature.
Such a complete software...

 
   
 

This concludes this test of the display calibration colorimeter of reference. I am so glad to discover how my two extra monitors are still correct and better calibrated than when using the previous colorimeter generation.

  i1Display Pro - X-Rite  
Color fidelity 9,5/10
Implementation / settings 10/10
Manufacturing quality 9,0/10
Quality/Price ratio 10/10

 

  What I like very much...  
 
  • The reference for an uncontrolled (non-standard) lighting environment in your home!
  • High-performance ADC function for calibrating laptop screens, Apple iMacs, and now even iPad or tablets under Android.
  • Such a fast calibration !
  • Precise calibration (Delta E standard 2000 very low),
  • Beautiful shades of grey with very little tone breaks even on TN panels, despite the absence of hardware calibration,
  • Beautiful grey neutralization,
  • Varied choices for color temperature,
  • All choices of screen types (backlighting) + beamer,
  • Compatible with 4K displays,
  • Advanced quality control
  • Multi monitors harmonization.
 
     
  What I regret...  
 
  • No simplified mode (but still a basic one), - Not sure it's a defect on this product!
  • Calibration a little redder than the i1Photo Pro 2 which looks greener in a "classic" environment,
  • There may be a small difference in color temperature between two colorimeters,
  • No tablet or TV calibration...
 
     
  My overall rating...  
  9,65 / 10  
     
  My conclusion...  
  i1Display Pro colorimeterSimply the best colorimeter on the market, if we except the too expensive Discus, in an uncontrolled lighting environment, so for "home"! Seven years after its release it is still relevant and I still use the model I acquired in 2011. Reliability is therefore a must.  
     
   
 
i1Display Pro - X-Rite

$244.78

$244.78
$279.99
$244.78
 
   
 
 
Here is the next part and the end of my test of the X-Rite i1Display Pro...  
 
- Complete review of the i1Display Pro
- Next : ICC profile check
  - Quality control
- Calibration with the i1Display Pro
- Conclusion and rating

- Why and how to calibrate your monitor ?
- How to choose your monitor ?


 

Calibrate your photo printerwith the best quality/price ratio: i1 Studio !

Read my Full review...  

$489.00

Calibrate your monitor with the best
quality/price ratio: Colormunki Display !

Read my Full review...

$151.92

   
 

 

     

 

 

 
 

 

       

From 2002, this Website offers...
 

This site dedicated to color management for photographers and videographers, beginners or professionals, visited by more than 328,000 people last year, offers on the one hand to help you easily understand and put into practice the color management of your photos and on the other hand helps you make the best investments with more than 70 hardware or software reviews since April 2002 in French and 2014 in English! It is the result of a patient work and a long experience shared by a professional but above all passionate photographer !

 

Where do the tested products come from ? Is my opinion completely independent ?

All the products I talk about on this site have been tested by me either following a personal purchase, a friendly loan, during a training session at a customer's site or after a manufacturer's loan. In any case, I decide what I want to test and even if, in the past, some brands were "disappointed" by my conclusions, things are moving today and my impartial opinion is more and more appreciated...

 

How is this site financed? What is my business ethics?

This site is largely free and yet without any product placement and without advertising. Why? But because I made a choice

 

fifteen years ago ! However, it must be recognized that it is lucrative and that it keeps many Internet sites alive.

So I asked myself the question : what can I do because this site can only grow with regular income, like the others ? How can I continue to make information accessible free of charge, which I have historically done since April 2002 ?


     


Thanks to affiliation : every time you click on the links on this site to my partner shops, they know that you come from me and give me a small percentage of what you buy : my buying advice or anything else. Remember to use my links when you buy from them ! So it costs you nothing and everyone wins : you, them, me ! And as I live in my time, I try to work as much as possible with sites that promote social ethics in their companies. In any case, I try to offer you a varied choice of possibilities to support me...

 

Legal informations

Legal information is available on my page Legal information - Contact me...

 
 

 

     

 

 

Top



 

Sitemap   |   About  Legal information